Thursday 22 November 2012

General Synod: Vote on Women Bishops

On Tuesday the governing body of the Church of England;- General Synod, voted on the issue of allowing women to be ordained as Bishops in the Church. Synod is made up of 3 'houses' Bishops, Clergy and Laity. For a measure to be approved it needs to gain a majority of two-thirds of the vote in each of the 3 houses. The houses of Bishops and Clergy voted clearly in favour but the house of Laity was much closer. Here there were 132 votes for 74 against and 9 abstentions. The house of Laity needed just a further 6 'yes' votes for the bill to pass but because it fell short the bill failed.

There have been a variety of reactions to this as you might expect. Much sadness from those who have worked tirelessly over many years to try and make women Bishops happen. There have been questions over the way Synod works, with many suggesting that it doesn't. 42 of the 44 dioceses voted in favour of Women Bishops, so why does General Synod not reflect this? I read a comment that said you can be president of the United States with 51% of the vote but not a female bishop with 74% of the vote. Many other countries in the worldwide Anglican communion are in shock as they already have Women Bishops. Others are delighted that the measure failed, including many women.

John Sentamu, the Archbishop of York, suggested in a radio interview that it was not the idea of women bishops that was rejected but rather the legislation that the church was suggesting to offer an alternative for those who in all good conscience could not receive the ministry of a female bishop.

The outgoing Archbishop of Canterbury, Rowan Williams, urged Synod to rebuild trust. The Archbishop elect, Justin Welby, tweeted that is was 'a grim day' for the Church and is keen to see this issue resolved.

Personally I am in favour of Women Bishop's and do not think the events of the last few days have done much to endear the work and mission of the Church to the watching world. However, the thing that makes me most sad is to see the in-fighting between the different 'sides'. More than anything now is a time for much love, grace and care for one another and a huge amount of prayer. This issue, along with the many other contentious issues that the church faces, is not going to go away and will, in time, need to be revisited and resolved. However, nothing should take us away from the great commission to go and make disciples and share the good news of the love of Christ with all.